Kayaking to Alligator Light Reef (lighthouse) .. of Fishes, Wreckers, Pirates and Keys History!

There are no alligators,

just a pretty reef and a tall light!

.

Kayaking to Alligator Lighthouse and the surrounding reef off Islamorada.

.

Lighthouses hold a special place in our collective psyche. Though they are simply beacons and markers, their sight brings to mind romanticized images from the past. Situated along the frontiers of the world of people, they mark out the borders of the wild and unpredictable world at large.  In the days of yore before satellite imaging, sonar mapping and very accurate charts, lighthouses were essential to safe passage for all vessels. Close to home, here in South Florida, the chain of islands and reefs bordering on the Gulf Stream, our “Florida Keys” proved treacherous for western powers shipping New World loot and treasures and there are still many wrecks lining the sea bottom all the way up to the Carolinas (the Graveyard of the Atlantic!)

.

The amazing views possible from the top of Alligator Reef Lighthouse.

.

Wrecking was a huge local industry in the 18th century, sometimes also spawning Keys pirates who would try and trick vessels to run aground on one of the reefs to generate more “business”. By the middle 19th century, a series of lighthouses began to be built along the edges of  the reefs of the the Florida Keys, extending from Key West to Cape Florida on Key Biscayne & beyond up along the Florida coastline. Alligator Reef Lighthouse or just “Alligator Light” is one of the six built, and the closest to land. It is relatively easy to get to being just about 4 miles offshore situated next to Alligator Reef.

Finding fascination in South Florida’s lighthouses, I have previously also paddled out to Miami’s Fowey Rocks Light, Key Largo’s Carysfort Light, the Sombrero Reef Lighthouse off Marathon, American Shoal Lighthouse  off Sugarloaf and the Sand Key Lighthouse off Key West! They are all part of the network of lighthouses built in the 19th century that also include Cape Florida Lighthouse, the Hillsboro Inlet Lighthouse and Jupiter Inlet Lighthouse that are accessible by land.

.

The USS Alligator circa 1822. Fair-use courtesy of Florida State Archives and http://www.keyshistory.org

.

The reef and light were named after the USS Alligator which shipwrecked there in November of 1822, although it would be another fifty years until the light was built in 1873! It is a beautiful and sturdy Victorian era tower, standing 136 feet tall, and has survived several major hurricanes and was an operational lighthouse/beacon until the summer of 2014!

.

Alligator Lighthouse in the 21st century before 2014.

.

Alligator Lighthouse circa 1873. Florida State Archives and http://www.reeflights.org

.

Alligator Reef  is a very popular place for boaters, snorkelers, and dive boat operators. Expect a crowd to build up especially on weekends! You will find a mostly family-friendly “sandbar” type atmosphere complete with music and folks enjoying themselves.

.

Days gone by – the simple beauty of Ektachrome slide film!
Alligator Light from the summer of 1982.

.

Kayaking out to Alligator Light is relatively easy, just realize that it is 4 miles offshore and ALL in open water, with NO place to get out!! Prepare ahead of time by studying the marine forecast and weather patterns. You want to be confident of at least two things .. light winds with calm seas, AND very low forecast probability for lightning storms! This means launching as early as possible from Indian Key fill, right off US1 where there is some very limited parking. Just make sure you don’t park in any private lots, even if they appear to be empty (like the Papa Joe’s Marina property – DO NOT park there) !!

.

Launch of the Mojito on the bay side from Indian Key fill.
Stick close to shore – this is a part of the intracoastal waterway!

.

A Sit-on-Top kayak is a great choice for this trip because the reef below the lighthouse is a great place for extended shallow water snorkeling! Alligator light is the closest of all the offshore reef lighthouses and the friendliest one for paddlers to head out to. It should take you about 45 minutes to an hour, certainly an hour and a half tops to paddle out. If you think it will take you longer than this you should probably reconsider doing this type of paddle because it won’t be fun anymore. Do not tie off to the lighthouse structure! Instead bring a good sand anchor as otherwise the current and wave action will cause you to drift away quickly. You may also need some extra line to daisy chain several kayaks together if needed.

.

Be sure to anchor in the sand NOT on top of any reef!

.

Alligator Reef has it’s own Sanctuary Preservation Area and there are special regulations such as no fishing that apply. The area map shows several white mooring buoys to tie off, but these are about half a mile away due SW from the lighthouse! Most people snorkel right under the light and the “wreck” immediately to the south. So unless you want to do a lot of swimming, you will need an anchor and the best place to anchor is in the sandy area N/NE of the lighthouse!

.

The white mooring buoys at Alligator Reef. Note that the reef itself is about half a mile from the lighthouse!
Image credit: NOAA

.

I would actually discourage anyone from paddling out there solo, unless you know exactly what you’re doing and have left a float plan with someone who cares about your well being. The reason being the combination of open water and unpredictable weather – you don’t want to be there all by yourself if something were to happen. It’s more fun to be a part of a small group that organize trips there from time to time.

.

Paddling out to Alligator Light in the early AM.

.

Remember that this is an 8 to 10 mile round trip – ALL in open water, with NO possibility of getting out anywhere. Plan accordingly and paddle within your limitations and the weather conditions!

Be sure to bring plenty of water to stay hydrated!

.

MOJITO kayak does the ALLIGATOR!

.

For this trip I chose the “Mojito”, an RTM Disco sit on top kayak. This is probably the nicest handling inexpensive plastic kayak for paddlers under 175 lbs. Granted, it’s a very wet ride, but this is actually a plus in the tropical heat. With the addition of thigh straps, it responds much like a proper sea kayak and is great to learn and practice kayaking and rescue skills. It’s also easy to roll and an excellent surf/play boat for South Florida waters!

Astute readers will note the use of a wing paddle. This is my favorite combination for paddling the Mojito! 🙂

.

Ridin’ the MOJITO (RTM Disco)! 🙂

.

The turquoise water is very clear and there’s lots of fish and coral to observe. In the summer the shallow waters of Alligator Reef are quite warm. You can snorkel for hours if you like, so be sure to bring your mask, fins & snorkel!

.

Above & Below: Alligator Light & Reef

 .

Please be careful NOT to step on coral heads and DO NOT touch the encrusted RUSTY steel frame of the old lighthouse!

.

Colorful fish of all shapes and sizes abound on Alligator Reef!

.

Thousands of fish surround the base supports of Alligator Reef Lighthouse.

.

Kayak snorkeling at Alligator Reef!

.

An Orangetail Mermaid?

.

There is great snorkeling all along Alligator Reef!

.

Alligator Reef sponges.

.

Alligator Reef corals.

.

Alligator Light rusting frame detail.

.

Alligator Reef is very shallow – watch your step!

.

Under the Alligator lighthouse frame support struts.

.

The encrusted and rusty steel frame of Alligator Light.

.

Alligator light seen from underwater!

.

Please remember: DO NOT step on or touch any coral!!

.

Family friendly party atmosphere surrounds the lighthouse!

.

Our kayaks daisy chain anchored off Alligator Light Reef.

.

Fortuitously, on the particular day of our trip, the “doors were open” so to speak and some folks were climbing up on top, so we took advantage and followed suit. I don’t believe this is normally the case, but I was not going to argue with opportunity, and the view from the top is truly spectacular! It felt almost impossible to take in enough of the beautiful blue-green aqua hues of the sky and clear waters below!!

.

Alligator Light tower steps .. slowly rusting since 1873.

.

Closeup of rusty tower steps.. they look like burnt crackers.

.

I bet the lighthouse keeper led a very chill life and must have been in great shape to climb the tower steps all the time. Surely it must have been quite an experience to ride out a storm on it! This lighthouse and the keeper did in fact ride out and survive the infamous Labor Day Hurricane of 1935 which was the strongest hurricane ever to hit the US with winds up to 200 mph. Although the glass and the original fresnel lens were destroyed, the lighthouse itself fared well, a testament to it’s construction and design!

.

Looking straight down from the top of Alligator Lighthouse.

.

Outstanding panoramic view from the top of Alligator Light!

.

360 spin around aerial view from the top of Alligator Lighthouse.
CLICK for interactive panorama!

.

At the top of Alligator Light.

.

I’m looking down at our kayaks 136 feet below!

.

Zoomed in on our colorful kayak flotilla!

.

Being inside the lighthouse, it’s easy to imagine being there back in time, a hundred years ago or more. In order to help preserve the Keys’ lighthouse cultural tradition of  nearly 140 years, the Florida Keys Reef Lights Foundation along with local artist resident Larry Herlth “Lighthouse Larry” have been pressing for the town of Islamorada to set up a lighthouse museum park with a series of 20 foot tall replicas he plans to build of all six lighthouses!

Larry is also the originator of the annual Open Water Swim for Alligator Lighthouse event, which now draws hundreds of eager swimmers sometimes including Olympic class talent. Larry was incidentally the first person to brave and complete the nine mile open water swim!

.

Beautifully ornate 19th century design of Alligator Lighthouse.

.

As of the summer of 2014, sadly the light is out and the Coast Guard will no longer be maintaining it. By July of 2015 the beacon was removed entirely and the lighthouse is now out of commission. Functionally it will be replaced, but not duplicated by a much shorter and simpler navigation beacon to be built nearby. Hopefully it will be acquired by an entity able to restore and maintain it for the public, and a new chapter could open for Alligator Light.

.

The last functioning beacon atop Alligator Reef Lighthouse.

.

In September of 2021 a new chapter has started for Alligator Reef Lighthouse!

It has been announced by the U.S. Secretary of the Interior that ownership of the lighthouse will be transferred to a local Keys non-profit entity “Friends of the Pool Inc.”. This is the same organization which hosts the annual “Swim for Alligator Lighthouse” event.

So the future looks promising for this historic Keys icon!

.

Beacon apparatus imported from New Zealand!
Removed in the summer of 2015.

.

Up until 2015, this modern setup was solar powered and ran off a bank of batteries.

.

Modern navigation beacon on Alligator Light circa 2012.
It was removed summer of 2015.

.

Back when I was a kid in the 80’s, it still had a real classic Fresnel Lens. I remember being very impressed by this very large classic glass lens and took a picture. I just recently found this slide of it from July 1982! 🙂

.

Alligator Reef Light classic fresnel lens, summer of 1982!

.

There’s room at the top of Alligator Light! 😉

.

I hope you’ve enjoyed these fine views from the top!

.

Gorgeous aquamarine views of surrounding Alligator Reef and clear waters.

.

Alligator Light was automated and solar powered right up until 2015!

.

Standing on nearly 140 years old steel decking on the top of Alligator Lighthouse.

.

Be sure to stay hydrated at Alligator Reef Light!

.

Remember that this is an 8 to 10 mile round trip – ALL in open water, with NO possibility of getting out anywhere. Plan accordingly and paddle within your limitations and the weather conditions!

Be sure to bring plenty of water to stay hydrated!

.

Alligator Reef Lighthouse as seen from Indian Key on a windy afternoon.

.

Miami paddler and adventurer Leah demonstrates the “Balance Brace” in the shallows off Indian Key.

.

On your return back to land, you can stop by and check out historic Indian Key which is right there along the route!

.

A paddler makes landing on nearby Indian Key.

.

Satellite view: It’s a direct straight shot to Alligator Light, there & back in a kayak!

.

Proximity of other Keys to Alligator Reef Lighthouse.

.

Satellite view of section of Alligator Reef.

.

Satellite view of Alligator Light.

.

.

.

Enjoy!

.

.

You may also like:

.

Fowey Rocks lighthouse – Paddling out to “The eye of Miami”.

.

Carysfort Reef Lighthouse – paddling into upper Keys nautical history!

.

Sombrero Reef Lighthouse – visiting the tallest of the reef lights via kayak!

.

Lower Keys paddling to American Shoal Lighthouse on the edge of the Gulf Stream!

.

Sand Key Lighthouse – kayaking to the “southern star” of the offshore Keys reef lights!

.

Kayaking the Biscayne Bay triangle: Cape Florida – Fowey Rocks – Soldier Key!

.

Paddling for Jesus in the Florida Keys dive country!

.

.

To learn more about Florida Bay and the Keys, I can recommend this informative and beautifully done book. There is a wealth of information inside along with incredible images by internationally recognized and top local Everglades photographers. If you like Florida Bay and the Keys, you will LOVE this book!

Full Disclosure: A few of my images are in it too.

“Florida Bay Forever” – Everglades Foundation book edited by Dan Burkhardt (with some photography by Flex Maslan).
Cover photo by Rob O’Neal

.

ART of the Bay – Florida Bay Landscapes

.

.

.

 .

© 2012-2022 Flex Maslan / kayakfari.com / awakenthegrass.com. All original photographs, artworks and music in this portfolio are copyrighted and owned by the artist, Flex Maslan, unless otherwise noted. Any reproduction, modification, publication, transmission, transfer, or exploitation of any of the content, for personal or commercial use, whether in whole or in part, without written permission from the artist is strictly prohibited.

All rights reserved!

…

DISCLAIMER:

The maps and images on this site are not intended for navigation, I am not a guide; use any and all information at your own risk! Your mileage may vary .. so use good judgement before venturing out!

This is a work of fiction. All characters appearing in this work are fictitious. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental. No skeleton, no barbie, nor person, nor kayak was harmed in the making of this work. The author is sorely responsible for the contents of this work!

…

I hereby disclaim any sponsorship, endorsement, nor association with any product or service described herein. The photographs, depictions, products, and ideas presented on this site are for informational purposes only. Your results may vary, and I do not imply nor guarantee the effectiveness, suitability, design or operation to adhere to any standard. I assume no legal responsibility for the implementation of anything herein presented! Use any and all information at your own risk! By using any and all information from this website, you accept the final liability for any use or possible associated misuse

.

With that said..
Blessings friends!

🙂